Every year, children leave cookies and milk for Santa on Christmas Eve — but have you ever wondered what his favorites actually are? We’ve collected some delicious recipes inspired by Mrs. Claus herself. Bake them with your kids after reading your Letter from Santa to keep the holiday spirit alive.

1. Classic Sugar Cookies

Santa never says no to frosted sugar cookies shaped like stars, trees, or reindeer. Decorate them with sprinkles and colored icing.

2. Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies

Warm, gooey chocolate chip cookies are always a hit — especially with a glass of milk.

3. Gingerbread Men

These spiced cookies smell like Christmas itself. Add candy buttons and icing smiles for extra charm.

4. Peppermint Bark Bites

A mix of white chocolate and crushed peppermint, these bite-sized treats are festive and refreshing.

5. Oatmeal Raisin (Rudolph’s Pick!)

Rumor has it that Rudolph prefers oatmeal raisin cookies — leave a few out with some carrots for the reindeer.

Try more cookie ideas from Taste of Home’s Christmas Cookies.

Want to add even more magic? Pair these cookies with a personalized letter from Santa waiting by the fireplace.

No matter which recipe you choose, baking Santa’s favorite cookies is about more than sweets — it’s about building traditions that make every Christmas magical.